Who composed “The 24”?
Generations of singers learned “The 24” from Alessandro Parisotti’s Arie antiche (1885) and the subsequent Schirmer anthology (1894). Both of these collections festooned the arias with 19th-century romanticism and contain many misattributions. Below you’ll find the corrected provenance of each aria, along with a clickable source picture.
Vittoria, vittoriaGiacomo Carissimi (1605-1674)Settledthe sameCantata Amante sciolto d'amore, 17th centuryText by Domenico Benigni.
Vergin, tutt’amorFrancesco Durante (1684-1755)Probablethe sameWordless solfeggio, Solfèges d'Italie, late 18th centuryLike "Danza, danza", a vocal exercise given words in the 19th century.
Tu lo saiGiuseppe Torelli (1658-1709)Disputedthe sameLast movement of the cantata Come potesti mai lasciarmi, infida?; Dresden manuscript, missing since 1945Known only from Albert Fuchs's 1901 adaptation. His manuscript was marked just "Torelli" and was taken to the USSR after the war. The same text was set by Bencini, and other copies credit Perti and Alessandro Scarlatti. The scan shown is Fuchs's 1901 print.
Sebben crudeleUnknownDisputedLong credited to Antonio CaldaraManuscript score of La costanza in amor vince l'inganno, Act I, scene 3; Conservatorio di Santa Cecilia, Rome, G.Mss.184, ff. 14v–15rThe score's title page names Caldara, but Caldara's own 1701 score of this opera, and the copies from its 1711 Rome revival, set the same words to completely different music (Nakamaki, 2010). Originally a 160-bar motto aria in E minor; Parisotti cut it to 83 bars.–
Se tu m'amiAlessandro ParisottiProbableLong credited to Giovanni Battista PergolesiFirst printed in Parisotti's Arie antiche, 1885No earlier source exists, and no scholar now accepts it as Pergolesi's. Parisotti very probably wrote it himself. Text by Paolo Rolli.
Se Florinda è fedeleAlessandro Scarlatti (1660-1725)Settledthe sameLa donna ancora è fedele, Naples, 1698
Quella fiammaFrancesco Conti (1681-1732)SettledLong credited to Benedetto MarcelloCantata Dopo tante e tante pene; manuscript, c. 1727, headed "Del Sig:r Fran:co Conti"In 1991 Paton still knew no authentic source for it. Manuscripts naming Conti are now catalogued in Meiningen and Berlin (shown here). The recitative "Il mio bel foco" that made it Marcello's was written by Carl Banck for an 1880 edition.
Pur dicesti, bocca bellaAntonio Lotti (1667-1740)Disputedthe sameL'infedeltà punita, Venice, 1712Lotti shared this opera with Carlo Francesco Pollarolo, and the aria may be Pollarolo's. The full score is lost; the aria survives in single copies, like the Paris manuscript shown here. Not from Arminio, as often printed.
Pietà, Signore!François-Joseph Fétis (1784-1871)ProbableLong credited to Alessandro StradellaFétis's manuscript for his Paris "historical concerts" (from 1832), headed "Aria di chiesa, dal celebre Stradella (1667)"; first printed in 1838 as "Se i miei sospiri"Not Stradella: a 19th-century piece passed off as Baroque, as the false heading in the scan shows. Fétis is the usual answer; Niedermeyer and Rossini have also been named.
Per la gloria d'adorarviGiovanni Bononcini (1670-1747)Settledthe sameGriselda, London, 1722Written for the castrato Senesino.
O del mio dolce ardor see belowChristoph Willibald Gluck (1714-1787)Settledthe sameParide ed Elena, Vienna, 1770A Classical opera aria, not a Baroque one.–
Non posso disperarGiovanni Bononcini (1670-1747)SettledLong credited to De LucaEraclea, 1692Printed under the name "De Luca"; the opera's 17th-century manuscripts show it is Bononcini's.
NinaAnonymousDisputedLong credited to Giovanni Battista PergolesiThe Favourite Songs in the Opera call'd Li Tre cicisbei ridicoli, London, c. 1749Printed as an aria sung by Filippo Laschi, with no composer named. Not by Pergolesi. Vincenzo Ciampi is often proposed, but it has never been proved.
Nel cor più non mi sento see belowGiovanni Paisiello (1740-1816)Settledthe sameLa molinara, Naples, 1788A Classical opera aria, not a Baroque one.–
Le violetteAlessandro Scarlatti (1660-1725)Settledthe samePirro e Demetrio, Naples, 1694Its first words are "Rugiadose, odorose".
Lasciatemi morire!Claudio Monteverdi (1567-1643)Settledthe sameL'Arianna, Mantua, 1608The lament is all that survives of the opera. The scan shown is its 1623 Venice print, the only surviving copy. We publish Lasciatemi morire in the Parisotti arrangement since the original is considerably longer than the familiar version. If you'd like the original published, get in touch.
Già il sole dal GangeAlessandro Scarlatti (1660-1725)Settledthe sameL'honestà negli amori, Rome, 1680
Danza, danza, fanciulla gentileFrancesco Durante (1684-1755)Probablethe sameWordless solfeggio, Solfèges d'Italie, late 18th centuryDurante wrote a vocal exercise. The words and the piano part were added in the 19th century.
Come raggio di solAntonio Caldara (1670-1736)Disputedthe sameGemme d'antichità, no. 77, London, between 1863 and 1878Nothing is known of its origin before that 19th-century printing. Paton: no one can yet say whether it is genuine Caldara or a Romantic forgery.–
Che fiero costumeGiovanni Legrenzi (1625-1690)Settledthe sameEchi di riverenza, op. 14, Bologna, 1678From a cantata collection, not an opera. Schirmer's version is Carl Banck's 1880 arrangement, with the barlines moved.
Caro mio benTommaso Giordani (1733-1806)ProbableLong credited to Giuseppe GiordaniPrinted by John Preston, London, c. 1785Not Baroque at all: a late-18th-century concert song, sung in London by Pacchierotti. Tommaso is now the likelier Giordani; Bertoni has also been proposed.
Amarilli, mia bellaGiulio Caccini (1551-1618)Settledthe sameLe nuove musiche, Florence, 1602Text by Guarini.
Alma del coreUnknownDisputedLong credited to Antonio CaldaraSame manuscript score, Act II, scene 19 (numbered 20 in the score); Conservatorio di Santa Cecilia, Rome, G.Mss.184Originally a duet for the lovers Atalanta and Meleagro; Ludwig Landshoff (1912) printed only Atalanta's stanza. Like "Sebben, crudele", it is not in Caldara's own score of the opera.–
Beyond The 24
AriaComposerLong credited toEarliest known sourceClick source
Bist du bei mirGottfried Heinrich Stölzel (1690-1749)SettledLong credited to Johann Sebastian BachNotebook for Anna Magdalena Bach, Leipzig (the 1725 book; this entry made in the 1730s)From Stölzel's opera Diomedes (Bayreuth, 1718), whose printed libretto has the text. The copy in the Bach family notebook made it BWV 508; a version with strings survives at the Sing-Akademie zu Berlin.
Delitie e contentiFrancesco Cavalli (1602-1676)Settledthe sameIl Giasone, Venice, 1649Jason's entrance aria. Often printed as "Delizie contente"; Delitie e contenti is the spelling of Cavalli's own time.
Sento nel coreAlessandro Scarlatti (1660-1725)Settledthe sameCantata Sento nel core certo dolore; manuscript copiesThe first aria of the cantata. None of the nine surviving manuscripts is in Scarlatti's hand.
Star vicinoAnonymousSettledLong credited to Salvator RosaFirst printed by Charles Burney, A General History of Music, London, 1789Burney found it in a songbook copied after Salvator Rosa's death and printed it under Rosa's name, as the scan shows. Frank Walker showed in 1949 that Rosa wrote none of the book's music.
Gluck and Paisiello. Schirmer’s 24 includes two Classical-era opera arias, Gluck’s O del mio dolce ardor (1770) and Paisiello’s Nel cor più non mi sento (1788). We publish art songs and Baroque arias only, so neither is in our catalogue.
Have insights into “The 24”? Get in touch